sect and religion
To the Jews, early Christians were just another fanatical group focused
around a charismatic leader. Similarly, the sect of the Shakers would not have
emerged from small group called the Wardley Society -- or stood out among the
other small groups that arose in its day -- without the direct personal
inspiration and motivation of Ann Lee.
The same conclusion is true for the many medieval heretical preachers who
inspired hearers throughout Europe. For them, the sources of spiritual
authority were at issue. From the medieval perspective, it was universally accepted
that the ultimate source for all authority and authoritative knowledge is God.
Conflict arose from the insistence by the Church that it alone provided
relationship with and definition for that authority. Individuals whose experience
told them that they could perceive God directly -- through the disciplines of
mystical practices, through immediate divine inspiration, or through purity of
life in imitation of Christ -- had to choose between an heretical identity, or
submission to the authority of the Church.
For lack of a way out, the medieval solution to persecution was extermination,
asphyxiation, reconversion, or survival in the mountains.